Increasingly, it also handles the postwar issues of legal claims about war crimes committed previously. But some have a long life in this world, a history most often of service to the powersthatbe, but also, sometimes, an oppositionist history. This workshop aims to illuminate the invention of collateral damage. Just war theory and operation enduring freedom, arizona journal of international and comparative law, vol.
Western emphasis on the use of precision weapons or simply foregoing a strike to avoid collateral casualties supports this claim. The inherent right to self defence and proportionality in. View academics in ethics in war collateral damage and just war theory on academia. Oct 30, 2006 participants suggested that just war theory makes war thinkable in an era when the devastation of war is particularly great. A critical analysis of a soldiers duty to prevent collateral damage. This paper was borne out of a realworld targeting query. Even just war theory does not allow for these actions, or places stringent limits guided by principles of discrimination and proportionality. On such occasions, we sometimes hear pronouncements that just war theory is hopelessly flawed. The theory of just war began in the service of the powers. The unintended deaths of civilians in war are too often dismissed as unavoidable, inevitable, and accidental.
If a tyrant cannot be eliminate because to do it implies collateral damages, this means. Violence the concept of collateral damage is morally important, analytically difficult, and subject to much abuse in. Over the centuries, it has, however, commanded a substantial influence from christianity, enlightenment philosophy, and western secular academia. A great deal has been written both defending and crticizing the doctrine of double effect.
Just war theory sets forth standards, both jus ad bellum rules governing if a war may be fought and jus in bello rules governing how a war is fought, standards which must be met if a war is to be considered just christian philosophers have posed numerous notions designed to restrain. Collateral damage and the enemy british yearbook of. It provides a clear definition of terrorism, an analysis of what makes terrorism morally wrong, and a ruleutilitarian defence of noncombatant immunity, as well as discussions of the allied bombings of cities in world war ii, collateral damage, and the clash between rights theories and utilitarianism. Our nations cause has always been larger than our nations defense. In connection with warfare and related forms of political violence see war. The theory of just war is known in variant forms since antiquity and several versions exist within both religious and philosophical. Jus in bello and collateral damage considerations for collateral casualties are addressed in the just war tradition, an influential theory on the ethics of war and peace which employs a set of universal, moral rules of war that provide a moral framework for evaluating the justice of all aspects of war.
Just war theory, theodicy, the doctrine of double effect and utilitarianism collectively suggest collateral damage as merely a reflection of more general authority and governance imperfections p. Kamm failures ofjust war theory 655 since fewer noncombatants might be killed in terrorbombing that brought a war to its end than as collateral damage in a. If a t yrant cannot be eliminate because to do it implies collateral damages, this means. Preserving their jus in bello protections penn state law elibrary. Apr 08, 2014 policies of targeted assassination by drone strike render conceptions of just war redundant. Cuttingedge technologiesdrones, cyber weapons, autonomous weaponscould reduce collateral damage, but their ease of use could also breed more conflict by lowering. A doctrine or system of moral conduct or virtue, where moral is defined as of or. As a result, the tradition evolved into a myriad of separate branches, which differ in their substantive contents, yet use.
Apr 28, 20 if so, the deliberate killing of innocent people isnt, after all, what makes terrorism distinctively morally wrong, and much, much worse than the kind of war that allows for extensive collateral damage including the current war on terrorism and the amount of such damage it brings about. Different cultures would have different ways of valuing the suffering endured by their soldiers. Jus in bello and collateral damage considerations for collateral casualties are addressed in the just war tradition, an influential theory on the ethics of war and peace which employs a set of universal, moral rules of war that provide a moral framework for evaluating the justice of. Increasingly, it also handles the post war issues of legal claims about war crimes committed previously. Despite these problems, i argue that just war theory is a useful method of inquiry into the problems of contemporary war. List of books and articles about just war doctrine. Michael walzer on terrorism and just war institute for. So mapping groundwater on the arabian peninsula figured to be a cinch for the egyptianborn director. In war, what level of collateral damage is considered. So mapping groundwater on the arabian peninsula figured to be a cinch for the egyptianborn director of. Dropping bombs on the munitions factory and destroying an unoccupied warehouse next door might indeed be justifiable collateral damage. Jun 05, 2012 in just war theory, recent attention has focused on the cessation of hostilities and establishment of a lasting peace, given problems with recent insurgencies. For an entire postwar generation, national security meant protection fr om nuclear attack. Click download or read online button to get collateral damage book now.
As information warfare capabilities have grown in recent years, the possibilities of war crimes with cyberattacks have increased. The censorship tools inspect dns queries near the isps boundary routers for sensitive domain key. Amost all example used to illustrate it outside the war context, concerning abortion and euthanasia. Civilian collateral damage and the law of war obligations of defenders not to commingle civilian and military objects welcome instapunditeers. This was arguably thanks in part to the global war on terror, which had the bush administration, the british government and other western allies describing civilians as collateral damage. Under just war theories proportionality has long been regarded as one of the elements for determining whether resort to war is justified. Civilian collateral damage and the law of war obligations. It merely argues that if there are supreme emergencies as walzer describes them, then situations in which war can justifiably be waged are, and ought to be, such emergencies. This is a study about just war theory, and its application in modern circumstances. Trenchant and wellwritten analysis of recent american military operations in iraq, afghanistan, and pakistan. Collateral damage an overview sciencedirect topics. Collateral damage and its acceptability within a culture depends on that cultures inherent values and attitudes to suffering and imposition of force. Academics in ethics in war collateral damage and just war.
That assumption might seem to demand a pacifist rejection of all war, for any sustained war effort requires military operations that predictably kill many noncombatants as collateral damage, and presumably at least most noncombatants. Sep 24, 2019 implicit in the theory of just war is a theory of just peace, walzer said, meaning noncombatant immunity protects not only individual noncombatants but also the group to which they belong. Just war theory some wars are just and some are not. For michael walzer, this triumph of just war theory is a sign of moral progress through which moral theory has been incorporated into military strategy and serves as a real constraint on the fighting of wars. Just war theory depends at least in part on the drawing of boundaries, including those between people who can legitimately be killed and those who cannot, circumstances in which this killing is and is not legitimate, and between intended as opposed to merely foreseen killing. Restraint or enabler of war critical asian studies. For example, jean elshtain argued after the 1991 gulf war that despite. The changing moral economy of war 21 22 november 2017 western sydney university, sydney, australia. The western theory of just war finds genesis in augustines deliberations on christianity and warfare. Covert operations and the terrorist attacks on september 11, 2001 on september 11, 2001 the definition of national security changed for most u. Will just war theory influence the use of military force more than international law.
Protecting the victims of war marcus schulzke there are strong moral and legal pressures against harming civilians in times of conflict, yet neither just war theory nor international law is clear about what responsibilities belligerents have to. Jan 01, 2017 just war theory, theodicy, the doctrine of double effect and utilitarianism collectively suggest collateral damage as merely a reflection of more general authority and governance imperfections p. Articles just war theory power that saves us both from that moral excess and that political folly. In justwar theory, recent attention has focused on the cessation of hostilities and establishment of a lasting peace, given problems with recent. The collateral damage can be justify on the bases of doctrine of double effect used by middle ages catholic theologians. The article then brings together the data on the changes in the types of wars fought and the shift from mainly military to mainly civilian warrelated deaths and asks what continuing regulatory effect the collateral damage rule can be expected to exert when the data on warrelated deaths will inevitably mean that the rule has utterly failed to. Uninvolved outsiders and large scale collateral damage are specifically excluded. The main ethical problems of cyberweapons in regard to ruses, secrecy, and collateral damage are examined, and analogies drawn to biological weapons. Just war theory and democratization by force army university press. List of books and articles about just war doctrine online. Pdf collateral damage and the principle of due care. Oct 26, 2001 war on terrorism the war in afghanistan and rising tensions in the middle east have temporarily put on hold efforts by scientists from islamic nations to strengthen ties among themselves and with the west farouk elbaz led the team that chose where the apollo landers set down on the moon.
Do drone strike assassinations render conceptions of just. Collateral damage is any death, injury, or other damage inflicted that is an unintended result of military operations since the development of precision guided munitions, military forces often claim to have gone to great lengths to minimize collateral damage critics of use of the term collateral damage see it as a euphemism that dehumanizes noncombatants killed or injured during combat. Just war doctrine and the international law of war citeseerx. There are two main principles coady, 2005 for the conduct of a just war. Considerations for collateral casualties are addressed in the just war tradition, an influential theory on the ethics of war and peace which employs a set of universal, moral rules. The project of just war theory has enjoyed a long and distinguished pedigree, dating back to the ancient grecoroman philosophy. The principle of discrimination, which restricts the types of weapons and methods that can be used and the targets that can be considered legitimate. It is an issue that stems from social and economic injustices. The collateral damage of internet censorship by dns injection. Collateral damage that is one of the central terms in semantic warfare. Protecting the victims of war marcus schulzke there are strong moral and legal pressures against harming civilians in times of conflict, yet neither just war theory nor international law is clear about what responsibilities belligerents have to correct harm once it has been inflicted.
Implicit in the theory of just war is a theory of just peace, walzer said, meaning noncombatant immunity protects not only individual noncombatants but also the group to which they belong. The collateral damage of internet censorship by dns injection anonymous. War on terrorism the war in afghanistan and rising tensions in the middle east have temporarily put on hold efforts by scientists from islamic nations to strengthen ties among themselves and with the west farouk elbaz led the team that chose where the apollo landers set down on the moon. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Collateral damage download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Terrorism and the ethics of war by stephen nathanson. Augustine of hippo 354430 was the first christian writer to describe the four conditions that must be met in order for a war to be just, but the roots of justwar theory go back even to nonchristian romans, particularly the roman orator cicero. A doctrine or system of moral conduct or virtue, where moral is defined as of or relating to principles of right and wrong behavior. Oct 22, 2017 western just war theory places a premium on avoiding the intentional targeting of, and unintended collateral damage to, noncombatants. We fight, as we always fight, for a just peacea peace that favors human liberty. A case for taking nonlethal action against civilians who discover hiding soldiers. Just as the destruction of the group cannot be a legitimate purpose of war, observed walzer, so it cannot be a legitimate practice in war.
I challenge this principle of risk by arguing that it is justified neither as a principle that guides the conduct of combat soldiers, nor as a principle that guides commanders in the us. A critical analysis of a soldiers duty to prevent collateral casualties. Ethics in war collateral damage and just war theory research. The same goes for the primary targetaim z just on the enemy side, that is in addition to the. Most people, even if unaware of it, adopt a form of just war theory jwt, which has informed international law and is frequently invoked by political leaders in discussions of. Wars against criminal dictators causing collateral damage strengthen the perceived legitimacy of those dictators. Ethics in war collateral damage and just war theory. If so, the deliberate killing of innocent people isnt, after all, what makes terrorism distinctively morally wrong, and much, much worse than the kind of war that allows for extensive collateral damage including the current war on terrorism and the. The original instapundit post had a bad link my fault it is here, on proportionality and jus ad bellum. The theory of the just war deals with the justifica tion of the war jus ad bellum and how it must be fought jus in bello to r espect the moral principle s which govern our individual or. Accountability for killing moral responsibility for collateral damage in americas post911 wars neta c. Shalom argues that the war in afghanistan and pakistan is unjust because it has violated the principles of last resort, right authority and proportionality. Jun 22, 2015 most people, even if unaware of it, adopt a form of just war theory jwt, which has informed international law and is frequently invoked by political leaders in discussions of war. How capitals war on labor killed detroit find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate.
Anne schwenkenbecher 2014 journal of military ethics 1. Cheryl abbate marquette university assuming the risk. The triumph of just war theory and the dangers of success. Policies of targeted assassination by drone strike render conceptions of just war redundant. Collateral damage is any death, injury, or other damage inflicted that is an unintended result of military operations since the development of precision guided munitions, military forces often claim to have gone to great lengths to minimize collateral damage.
If you accept this idea, it becomes important to figure out the conditions under which wars are just. Pdf on jan 1, 2017, josh murray and others published collateral damage. Crawford focuses on the causes of these many episodes of foreseeable. The second part of the article begins by criticizing a standard justification for causing collateral side effect deaths in war and offers an alternative justification that makes use of the idea of group liability. Keywords collateral damage, dirty hands, just war theory, michael walzer, supreme emergency. Just war is a concept that governs the conditions under which a war can be waged and how it can be waged. This book begins with the assumption that individual rights exist and stand as moral obstacles to the pursuit of national, no less than personal, interests. The catholic churchs teaching on just war developed very early.
1669 1053 1056 543 246 373 875 1180 554 1035 398 1557 1594 739 1609 386 1599 1660 1105 1149 719 538 574 49 238 697 993 478 465 1427 483 204 363 569 434 1182 1235 900 615 253 234 38